Pinball Battles in Surprise, AZ: Who Ruled the Playfield at Player 1 Arcade?

On March 10, 2025, the Player 1 Arcade 2025 Series 3 (#2) tournament brought together 24 players for a fast-paced, five-round showdown. With a comfortable 75°F and clear skies outside, the real storm was happening inside—on the playfields. Over the course of three and a half hours, players clashed flippers on some of the best pinball machines around, all hoping to take home the top prize.

A Retro Wonderland in Surprise, AZ

Walking inside feels like stepping into a neon-lit time machine, where the hum of CRT screens and the rhythmic sounds of flippers create an atmosphere straight out of the golden age of gaming. The arcade boasts an impressive mix of pinball machines, retro arcade cabinets, and a well-stocked bar—because what’s better than a cold drink while chasing high scores? The walls are decked out with striking murals, including a tribute to Take on Me, as well as iconic legends like David Bowie and Prince. Even the bathrooms get in on the action, each one sporting a different theme.

While they don’t serve food, visitors love the laid-back, social vibe of the space. Whether you’re a serious competitor or just looking to relive your childhood, Player 1 Arcade offers a little something for everyone. And if pinball is your game? You’ve found the right place.

A Battle for the Ages on Iron Maiden

Every tournament has that one match that gets the crowd talking, and in Round 2, it was all about Iron Maiden: Legacy of the Beast. This machine is relentless—just like the players who took it on. Dave Halley, a seasoned competitor with years of experience, played with the confidence of someone who’s flipped his way through over 500 IFPA events. He controlled the flow, hit his shots, and dominated the playfield like Eddie storming into battle.

But Walter Dony wasn’t about to let him walk away with an easy win. A solid Phoenix-based competitor, Walter’s aggressive playstyle kept Dave on edge, making for a thrilling back-and-forth. In the end, Dave edged him out for first place, but Walter’s second-place finish showed he’s a player to watch.

Further down the ranks, James Theisen, an unranked player in official IFPA standings, played like he had something to prove, securing third place in the match. Meanwhile, Del Kyger, a tournament regular, gave a solid effort despite struggling against some of the game’s brutal drains.

Breaking Down the Pinball Lineup

With 16 machines in the tournament rotation, there was no shortage of variety. Here’s a closer look at some of the standouts:

Stranger Things (Pro) – Stern, 2019

This machine transports players to Hawkins, Indiana, capturing the essence of the popular Netflix series. Players embark on a quest to unravel the mysteries surrounding the Hawkins National Laboratory, battling the Demogorgon and navigating the Upside Down. The Pro model features a custom sculpted, interactive Demogorgon bash toy, guarded by drop targets and a rotating ramp. All models include two hideout ball scoops, a Demodog spinner, three custom ramps, and game rules that immerse players into the eerie world of Stranger Things.

Foo Fighters (LE) – Stern, 2023

Released in March 2023, Stern’s Foo Fighters pinball machine is a vibrant tribute to the iconic rock band. Players embark on an intergalactic adventure with the band members, battling aliens to save humanity. The machine features 15 of Foo Fighters’ greatest hits, including “Everlong,” “My Hero,” and “Learn to Fly,” providing an electrifying soundtrack that complements the fast-paced gameplay. The playfield is adorned with hand-drawn artwork and custom animations, creating an immersive experience that captures the band’s energetic essence.

Dungeons & Dragons: The Tyrant’s Eye (Pro) – Stern, 2025

Stern’s Dungeons & Dragons: The Tyrant’s Eye, released in January 2025, brings the legendary tabletop role-playing game to the pinball arena. Players become members of the Dragonshield Guild, embarking on quests to defeat formidable foes like the dragon queen Tiamat and the beholder crime lord Xanathar. The machine boasts a campaign-based gameplay with multiple missions, an interactive dragon sculpture that reacts to hits, and a unique “PinSave” feature allowing players to save their progress. The collaboration with notable voice actors and artists adds depth to the storytelling, making it a standout in modern pinball design. ​

Guardians of the Galaxy – Stern, 2017

Launched in November 2017, Guardians of the Galaxy pinball machine immerses players in the Marvel universe alongside Star-Lord, Gamora, and Rocket Raccoon. The game features scenes from the blockbuster film, a mix of classic rock tracks, and challenging modes that require players to battle villains like Ronan the Accuser. Its engaging playfield design and dynamic soundtracks have made it a favorite among both casual players and pinball enthusiasts.​

The Walking Dead (Pro) – Stern, 2014

Stern’s The Walking Dead pinball machine, released in October 2014, captures the intense atmosphere of the popular TV series. Players fight to survive in a post-apocalyptic world filled with walkers, navigating through various modes that reflect the show’s dramatic scenarios. The game features a detailed playfield with zombie-themed toys and targets, challenging missions, and a gripping soundtrack that keeps players on edge.​

Cyclone – Williams, 1988

A classic from February 1988, Cyclone transports players to a carnival setting, complete with a roller coaster and ferris wheel. Known for its simple yet addictive gameplay, the machine features a rotating ferris wheel that captures the ball, a comet ramp, and a spook house. Its nostalgic theme and straightforward mechanics have cemented its status as a beloved title in pinball history.​

Each of these machines not only provided unique challenges during the tournament but also showcased the rich tapestry of pinball design and history, offering players and spectators a diverse and engaging experience.

Who Took Home the Victory?

After five rounds of competition, it was Dave Halley who walked away with the win. If there was ever a doubt about why he’s ranked among Arizona’s top 50 players, he erased it with a steady, calculated performance all night. His ability to read the ball and control the pace of play made him nearly untouchable in the later rounds.

John Stein might have traveled from Portland, Oregon, but he played like he was right at home. As a competitor ranked lower in his own state standings, John surprised the field with some clutch performances, securing second place and proving that experience—rather than ranking—can make all the difference on tournament day.

Andrew Kohtz finished in third, and if there was an award for most consistent play, he would have taken it. A Phoenix-based competitor, Andrew made it to the final rounds by staying focused and making smart decisions when it counted. His mid-tier state ranking didn’t tell the full story of how well he played on the night.

And then there was Joel Daniel, a Surprise, AZ local who showed up ready to compete. While he didn’t quite crack the top three, his fourth-place finish was well-earned. He outlasted several higher-ranked players and proved that on any given night, anyone can rise to the occasion.

Arizona’s Top 10 Pinball Players

The state rankings continue to shift, but here’s where Arizona’s best currently stand:

Wrapping Up

A huge shoutout to Jim Smith for running a smooth and competitive tournament, and of course, to Player 1 Arcade for hosting. The event had everything you could want—great competition, exciting games, and a reminder that pinball is alive and thriving in Arizona.

Congratulations again to Dave Halley for taking home the win. If you’re looking for your next pinball challenge, keep an eye on upcoming events at Player 1 Arcade by following them on Facebook. More tournaments, more high scores, and more pinball stories to come! Stay tuned.